Disciplinary Procedures for Care Staff
Ensuring high standards of conduct and performance among your care staff is essential to providing safe and effective care. As a care provider, maintaining a fair and transparent disciplinary process can help uphold these standards while also fostering a positive workplace culture. This guide outlines a step-by-step approach designed for care company owners and managers.
Navigating HR within the framework of the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and employment regulations can be highly complex, so we always recommend to seek professional advice on a case by case basis.
What is a Disciplinary Procedure?
A disciplinary procedure is a structured process used to address employee misconduct or performance issues. Depending on the severity of the situation, responses can range from informal conversations to formal disciplinary actions. For care providers this is an incredibly important process as misconduct from care staff can and does result in severe or even life-threatening consequences.
While it may involve reprimanding employees, the primary goal of a disciplinary procedure is to encourage improvement, support professional development, and safeguard the quality of care delivered.
Free 15 Minute Consultation
Here at Affinity Care HR, we pride ourselves on our care-industry expertise. If you’re interested in some extra expert advice, book a free 15 minute consultation today.
How to Conduct a Disciplinary Procedure in 6 Steps:
1. Determine Whether Formal Proceedings Are Necessary
Before initiating disciplinary action, assess whether informal resolution is possible. For instance, if a care worker arrives late once but has an otherwise good record, a brief, informal chat may suffice to prevent recurrence. Formal action should only be taken if informal steps are inadequate or the misconduct is more serious.
At this stage you may need to notify CQC depending on the severity of the issue. Registered providers must notify the CQC about certain changes, events and incidents that affect their service or the people who use it. Such events include allegations of abuse, serious injury or death of a service user.
You can view the full list of notifiable actions on the CQC website.
If said incident is a notifiable action you should reach out to your Local Authority Safeguarding Team and they can advise you further on the next steps.
In the most serious cases involving a criminal offence under investigation, the matter will be handled by the authorities. You must wait for a legal decision before taking any HR actions.
2. Investigate Alleged Misconduct
If formal proceedings are warranted, a thorough investigation is essential to ensure fairness and compliance with employment law. The investigation should focus on fact-finding, including:
Interviewing witnesses: This could involve speaking with colleagues, residents, or their families.
Gathering evidence: Examples include CCTV footage, attendance logs, care records, or written communications.
The investigation should be impartial and consider evidence both for and against the employee. Cases of misconduct within the care industry can often include very sensitive information, that is why it is vital to safely store and share any evidence gathered. In some cases, you may need to suspend the employee on full pay during the investigation, but this should be a last resort and clearly communicated as a neutral step.
3. Set Up a Disciplinary Meeting
If the investigation indicates misconduct, invite the employee to a disciplinary meeting. The invitation letter must:
Provide at least 48 hours notice of the meeting;
Inform the employee of their right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative;
Include all relevant evidence; and
Outline the allegations and potential outcomes.
Where possible, the meeting should be conducted by someone who did not carry out the investigation.
4. Conduct the Disciplinary Meeting
During the meeting:
Present the allegations and evidence.
Allow the employee to respond and present their defence.
If new information arises, you may need to adjourn to investigate further before making a decision.
5. Make a Decision
After reviewing all evidence and considering the employee’s response, decide on the appropriate course of action. This could range from no action to dismissal, depending on the severity of the misconduct. Key considerations include:
Fairness and reasonableness of the proposed action;
Any mitigating circumstances; and
Consistency with how similar cases have been handled.
6. Communicate the Outcome and Allow an Appeal
Inform the employee of your decision in writing, clearly explaining the rationale. Ensure they understand their right to appeal if they believe the decision is unfair. Appeals should:
Be conducted by someone not previously involved in the case;
Provide the employee with another opportunity to present their case; and
Conclude with a final written decision.
In the case of a Registered Manager (or Registered Individual) being suspended for 28 days or more, you must also notify this absence to the CQC.
Key Takeaways for Care Providers:
Maintain Balance: Consider all evidence, including points raised by the employee in their defence.
Explore Alternatives: Before dismissing an employee, consider options like retraining, reassignment, or demotion if appropriate and permitted by their contract.
Graduated Response: Use a step-by-step approach, escalating from verbal warnings to more serious actions as necessary, unless the misconduct warrants immediate dismissal.
CQC Complexity: Disciplining care staff whilst staying compliant with both employment laws and CQC regulations can be a challenge and we always advise providers to seek professional HR support.
By following these steps, care providers can handle disciplinary issues effectively, ensuring fairness and maintaining high standards of care.
